Few things sting as much as being met with stone-cold silence from someone you love. If you’ve ever found yourself tiptoeing around your partner, desperately attempting to break through their frosty facade, then you know exactly how confusing and painful the silent treatment can be. Is it a request for space, a display of profound hurt, or something more controlling? Let’s cut to the chase and talk about what really is going on and how you can maintain your sanity (and self-dignity) intact.
First of all, let’s clarify the difference between needing space and the silent treatment. Sometimes people just need a break from an emotionally charged situation or argument. This is what is known as a timeout, and trust me, it’s a good thing think about pressing pause so the two of you can both calm down and come back to it. A good timeout shouldn’t last more than a day, and whoever did the timeout should be the one to come back in and keep talking. That’s healthy emotional regulation and a sign of mutual respect.
The silent treatment, though, is a whole different beast. As Leslie Vernick says, it’s an indirect-aggressive way of punishing or controlling a partner. Instead of letting you know what you’re doing wrong, the silent partner withholds attention, affection, and communication.
This leaves you to wonder what you did to get in trouble and, typically, begging for their pardon. This isn’t about wanting space to sort things out it’s about getting you to pay for having inconvenienced them and laying the whole burden of the relationship at your feet.
If you’re the one being manipulated, it’s easy to fall into either of two traps. You might start desperately trying to salvage the relationship, apologizing for things you don’t even know you did, or going out of your way to get them back. Or you simply get angry and strike out, which just feeds into the narrative that you’re the problem. Either way, the silent partner becomes the innocent victim and you become the bad guy.
So, how does a healthy, self-respecting person handle it? The solution is to get out of this toxic dance. Don’t lash out at your partner or attack, just leave. Spend time with friends, follow your own passions, and remember that their silence is more an expression of their lack of control over emotions than a commentary on your worth.
You can invite them to chat when they’re ready say, with something as innocuous as, “I’m willing to talk about what’s going wrong when you’re willing to talk” but don’t beg, plead, or harass. Set the tone, then let them decide how to show up.
Prepare yourself: altering your response may not magically repair the relationship. Your partner might double down on the victim mentality or even reverse itself, going from silence to explosive anger. If this occurs, remain calm and establish firm boundaries.
If they start to attack you verbally, you have the power to say, “I hear that you’re upset, but I am not able to communicate when you’re attacking or blaming me. Let’s talk when you’re in a calmer state of mind.” And then leave and give them time to choose how to communicate in a better manner.
Lastly, you can’t force anyone to speak or take responsibility for their feelings. But you can look after your own emotional health by not playing the blame game. Remember, good relationships are based on honest communication and respect for each other not on punishment or manipulation. If you’re the only one who always gets the silent treatment, it’s an indication that you need to look after yourself and figure out what you truly want and deserve in a relationship.
Related
